12-13 November 2026, Utrecht University
Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies
See abstracts & bionotes below
Organizers: Gökçen B. Dinç (Utrecht University) and Birgit Meyer (Utrecht University)
Recent scholarship has demonstrated that “religion” and “the secular” are not universal categories, but historically produced formations shaped by Christian, post-Enlightenment, and Protestant epistemologies. Yet, one crucial category that has structured this distinction has received far less systematic attention: “superstition.” This symposium aims to conceptualize superstition as a constitutive “third” category—one that has actively shaped the boundaries of both religion and the secular in the modern world. The modern construction of “true” religion did not emerge solely through its differentiation from the secular, but also through the exclusion and reclassification of certain beliefs and practices as superstition, magic, or according to Christian discourse, “idolatry.” A great deal of research has examined superstition primarily in relation to witchcraft, magic, and the Reformation in medieval and early modern Europe, pointing out how the ways in which the triad of religion-science-superstition operated to oust particular practices and ideas as belonging neither to the domains of religion nor to science. More recent studies—particularly on modernity in East Asia and Turkey, as well as in West Africa—have shown that superstition functioned as a politically charged category. It was mobilized to redefine orthodoxy, discipline specific religious practices conducted by people out of the normative religious mainstream and produce modern subjects. Building on this emerging body of scholarship, this conference seeks to develop a global perspective on superstition as a key analytical category in the study of modern and contemporary societies. Across different regions—from East Asia and the Middle East to Europe, Africa, South Asia, and the United States—accusations of superstition have operated as technologies of governance, reform, and social differentiation. By foregrounding the political and ideological uses of superstition, the symposium aims to illuminate the contradictions, conflicts, and negotiations through which boundaries between superstition and related categories such as magic and idolatry have been constructed, both institutionally and in everyday life. By bringing scholars from diverse fields together, we want to address the following questions and corresponding ideas to promote further research:
* How did superstition function in the co-production of religion and the secular?
* What is the gain of adding superstition as a third category for critical religious studies?
* In what ways was superstition mobilized to regulate practices, bodies, and communities?
* How did the charge of practices as evidence of superstition relate to idolatry and the figure of the fetish?
* How did discourses of superstition intersect with gender, race, and class in producing, shaping and sustaining unequal power relations?
* How did individuals and communities labeled as superstitious respond to, appropriate, or subvert such accusations?
* What transregional or global connections can be traced in the circulation and transformation of the category of superstition?
* How is superstition employed in current times?
Thursday, 12 November 2026
Newtonlaan 201 – 3A.42 Bloeyendael room
13:00 – 13:15 Welcome and Introduction
13:15 – 14:00 Bring Your “Superstition” and Explain It
Please bring an object or a picture that is immediately related to the focus of our symposium: superstition. All superstition-related items will be put on an exhibition table and then be presented by all speakers/participants.
14:00 – 14.45 Kick-off: Why “superstition”?
Chair: Justine Bakker
Wouter Hanegraaff, Birgit Meyer and Gökçen B. Dinç
14:45 – 16:00 Panel 1
Chair: Birgit Meyer
Arjan Sterken, Radboud University
“Civilizing the Natives in the North: Accusations of Superstition in 19th Century Groningen, the Netherlands”
Verena Meyer, Leiden University
“Questions of Care: The Ethics of Manuscript Preservation and the Politics of Superstition in Islamic Indonesia”
16:00 – 16:15 Coffee/Tea Break
16:15 – 17:30 Panel 2
Chair: Erik Meinema
Asghar Seyed Gohrab, Utrecht University
“The Art of Sufis: Revisiting Ahmad Kasravi’s Views on Sufism”
Ufuk Erol, Leibniz-Institut für Europäische Geschichte
“Constructing Superstition: Sufism, Orthodoxy, and State Power in the Early Modern Ottoman Empire”
17:30 – 18:30 Keynote Lecture
Chair: Gökçen B. Dinç
Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm, Williams College (online)
“The Demon’s Gate: Towards a Global History of Religion–Science–Superstition”
19.15 Symposium Dinner (for all speakers and chairs) at Djakarta https://djakarta.nl
Friday 13th November 2026
University Library City Centre – Room E.0.21
Drift 27, 3512 BR Utrecht (Corner Keizerstraat and Wittevrouwenstraat)
09:45-11:30 Panel 3
Chair: Irene Stengs
Markus Balkenhol, Meertens Institute Amsterdam
“Trefu. Afro-Surinamese Food Taboos and the Entanglements of Memory, the Body and the Supernatural”
Gertrud Hüwelmeier, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
“The Transformation of Superstition into Intangible Cultural Heritage. Spirit Mediumship in late-socialist Vietnam”
Ananya Pattnaik, Indian Institute of Technology (online)
“Tales of Janis: Supernatural Threat, Accusations of ‘Guni-Garini/ Sorcery’ and Contestations
around Religious Boundaries”
11.30 – 11.45 Coffee Break
11:45 – 13:00 Panel 4
Chair: Ernst van den Hemel
Pooyan Tamimi Arab, Utrecht University
“Spinoza’s Account of Superstition and Critical Theory”
Gökçen B. Dinç, Utrecht University
“Gendering Superstition: Why Annemarie Schimmel was an Exception”
13:00 – 13:45 Lunch
13:45 – 15.30 Panel 5
Chair: Birgit Meyer
H. Işık, Mimar Sinan Fine Arts University (online)
“Negotiating Authority: The Continual Reclassification of Superstition in the Turkish Daytime Television Programme Müge Anlı ile Tatlı Sert”
Hermen Kroesbergen
“Superstition as Adding the Wrong Kind of Reality to Religion”
Adeyemi Johnson Adewowo, Afe Babalola University (online)
“Who Be Witch? Interrogating Superstition, Ageing, Gender and the Politics of Accusation in Contemporary Nigeria”
15.30-16.00 Final Discussion
16:15 – 17:30 Drinks at Hofmann
Abstracts and bionotes
Kick-off: Why “Superstition”?
Chair: Justine Bakker
Justine Bakker is Assistant Professor in Comparative Religious Studies at Radboud University Nijmegen. She specializes in esoteric, alternative, and heterodox forms of religion, in particular in the African diaspora. Justine was recently granted an ERC-starting grant for her project “Occult Atlantic: Chasing Higher Knowledge in North America, the Caribbean and West Africa.” Occult Atlantic studies the circulation of occult knowledge across the Atlantic since 1900.
Gökçen B. Dinç is a Marie Skłodowska-Curie Postdoctoral Research Fellow at Utrecht University’s Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies. She previously worked as a postdoctoral fellow at the University of Hamburg, Department of Turcology. She earned her PhD in history at Humboldt University-Berlin and is the author of two books and several articles on the gender and religious history of modern Turkey. Her research focuses on the social and gendered history and historiography of Islam and Sufism in the modern period, global religious history, and theory and method in the study of religion. Taking modern Turkey as its starting point, her work develops a postcolonial critique of modernity that challenges Eurocentric and Orientalist biases by foregrounding the experiences and voices of marginalized actors.
Wouter J. Hanegraaff is Professor of History of Hermetic Philosophy and Related Currents at the University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands. He is the author of New Age Religion and Western Culture: Esotericism in the Mirror of Secular Thought (Leiden 1996/Albany 1998); Esotericism and the Academy: Rejected Knowledge in Western Culture (Cambridge 2012); and Hermetic Spirituality and the Historical Imagination: Altered States of Knowledge in Late Antiquity (Cambridge University Press 2022) and Esotericism in Western Culture: Counter-Normativity and Rejected Knowledge (Bloomsbury 2025).
Birgit Meyer is professor of religious studies at Utrecht University. Trained as a cultural anthropologist, she studies religion from a material and postcolonial angle. In addition to her longstanding research in Ghana, she is interested in broader conceptual issues related to the multiple manifestations of religion in the past and present and the coexistence of people from diverse religious, ethnic, and cultural backgrounds. Characteristic of her work is her engagement with the corporeal, material, and political-aesthetic dimensions of religion from an anthropological perspective. Visual culture and religious images and artefacts play a central role in her work. Meyer initiated the comprehensive research programme Religious Matters in an Entangled World (www.religiousmatters.nl).
Panel 1
Chair: Birgit Meyer
(bionote above)
Arjan Sterken
Civilizing the natives in the north: Accusations of superstition in 19th century Groningen, the Netherlands
The subjugated populations of the occupied overseas colonies were submitted to a new phase in colonialism. Rather than being merely economically exploited, these populations were now also supposed to learn the traditions and behaviours of the dominant society. In other words, they needed to be ‘civilized’. Quite interestingly, a similar process was happening within the homelands of the colonial occupants. Within the ruling classes, a discourse started that did not merely want to ‘civilize’ the subjugated colonial populations but also the lower classes on the European mainland. Ministers, priests, doctors and teachers who were trained in the west of the Netherlands were sent out to different peripheral regions of the Netherlands in order to bring these people the right kind of culture and traditions. In such ‘civilizing’ processes, the term bijgeloof (superstition) was often evoked to demonstrate wrong dogma: belief in extra-social entities like ghosts and mermaids and the like was either superseded by scientific worldviews or was a degeneracy of Christianity. This paper examines the way how the term bijgeloof was applied by two groups of the ruling classes in Groningen, a northern province of the Netherlands, in the 19th century. The first group is teachers, whose deployment of the term is examined in questionnaires they filled out in 1828. The second group is public servants, exemplified by Marten Douwes Teenstra, who wrote numerous books on colonial politics, history, and Groningen folklore. Both groups, however, seem to have different opinions on the presence of bijgeloof and therefore the urgency of intervention. Most teachers denote that bijgeloof has decreased significantly in the last decades and is no longer a ‘social issue’, while Teenstra claims bijgeloof is alive and hinders the Groningen population in their development. Historical documents and book publications are examined to explain these differences of opinion and to determine how this concept functions within the ‘civilizing’ process of Groningen.
Arjan Sterken is a scholar of religion, specializing in mythology and folklore. He is a guest researcher at Radboud University, where he is finishing his PhD research on the ambiguity of ‘supernatural’ (extra-social) beings. Arjan specializes in folklore and mythology from India and the Germanic areas, with a dominant focus on Saxon (Nedersaksisch or Plattdeutsch) folklore. As a scholar, Arjan focuses predominantly on historical folkloric and mythological texts, but also considers modern sources and data in his teaching and research practices. Theoretical interests are in the field of hermeneutics, structuralism, and cognitive science of religion.
Verena Meyer
Questions of Care: The Ethics of Manuscript Preservation and the Politics of Superstition in Islamic Indonesia
Contemporary Indonesia is experiencing a boom in the digitization of Islamic manuscripts, a boom that is supported and carried out by transnational funding agencies, government institutions, scholars, and heritage activists. But not everybody agrees with the digitization of manuscripts. In public discourse, those who are unwilling to have their collections digitized are often said to harbor superstitions that manuscripts are magical objects and thus unsafe to handle. Proponents of digitization, by contrast, often frame their views as modern and pragmatic, unencumbered by outdated superstitions about manuscripts and their use. But while this struggle against superstitions is foregrounded in many public-facing discussions, during my ethnographic research among groups digitizing manuscripts in Sumatra, Java, and Sulawesi, I found that promoting modern views about manuscripts, or being perceived as modern, played little role in my interlocutors’ personal motivations. Instead, they would emphasize the benefit of digital preservation and access, conceptualizing it in explicitly Islamic terms as fulfilling a mandate (A. amāna) of extending the writers’ pious deeds — their efforts in composing books on Islamic topics for the benefit of readers — beyond their death (A. ʿamaljāriya). Here, digitization becomes part of a reciprocal relationship of care between the living and the dead. Meanwhile, people who refuse to have their manuscripts digitized often draw on a very similar rationale that foregrounds their relationship with elders. For them, digitization is not allowed precisely because letting strangers handle personal heirlooms does not constitute proper care and would result in a curse (I. kualat). Following this workshop’s invitation to consider superstition as a third category in the study of religion and secularism, this paper understands these controversies not as a clash between belief and rationalism, but rather as a confrontation of incommensurable ethical and ontological imaginaries based on specific understandings of obligations and care. In this controversy, the language of superstition is politically salient as it can be mobilized to render competing visions of care illegitimate and to authorize particular regimes of knowledge, access, and care while disqualifying others.
Verena Meyer is an Assistant Professor of Islam in South and Southeast Asia at the Leiden Institute for Area Studies. In her work, she draws on ethnographic field research and literary studies in Javanese, Malay, and Arabic to investigate questions of Islamic identity, the role of memory and the formation of heritage, and the transmission of knowledge across time and space. Her first book is titled Theologies of Remembering: Modernity, Ambiguity, and Transcendence in Islamic Indonesia (University of California Press, 2026). Her second project, funded by the NWO, investigates the digitization of Islamic manuscripts in Indonesia, asking how digitization transforms understandings of the meaning and use of writing and textuality.
Panel 2
Chair: Erik Meinema
Erik Meinema is an Assistant Professor Religion and Heritage at the department of Philosophy and Religious Studies at Utrecht University. His research focuses on religious diversity in East Africa. He is a member of the research group ‘Religious Matters in an Entangled World’ that is led by Birgit Meyer. A monograph based on his PhD research, entitled Regulating Religious Coexistence. The Intricacies of Interfaith Cooperation in Coastal Kenya has recently been published open access in the African Religions, Social Realities series of Ohio University Press. He is also interested in questions about materiality, religion, and (violent) conflict and has published two edited volumes on this topic with Brill and Routledge together with Lucien van Liere. From January 2025, he is working on a NWO-funded Veni-project entitled Art, Religion, or Heritage? Negotiating Indigenous African Traditions in the Religiously Diverse Context of Coastal Kenya.
Asghar Seyed-Gohrab
The Art of Sufis: Revisiting Ahmad Kasravi’s Views on Sufism
Ahmad Kasravi (1890-1946) was one of the leading intellectuals of the 20th-century Iran who wanted to reform Persian culture through severe criticisms of religion and spirituality, with the aim of creating a culture purified from irrationalities and religious dogmas. He published several essays and pamphlets, condemning Sufism and mystical poetry. In such works, he questions why medieval Persian intellectuals and mystical poets relied on religious doctrines and concepts rather than basing themselves on rational thinking and methodical reasoning (khirad). In his view, both religion and mystical poetry were impediments to progress. In this lecture, I analyse Kasravi’s Sufigari (“The Craft of Sufis,” 1943) and Hafez che miguyad (“What does Hafez Say?” 1942), in which he severely criticizes Sufism and Persian mystical poetry.
Asghar Seyed-Gohrab is Professor of Iranian and Persian Studies at Utrecht University in the Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies. He has published extensively on Persian literature, mysticism and religion. His publications range from Persian poetry to Sufism and the role of religious and mystical motifs and metaphors in Iran-Iraq War (1980- 1988) and how peaceful religious injunctions are used to justify violence. He authored Soefisme: een levende traditie (Amsterdam: Prometheus/Bert Bakker, 2015 third print); The True Dream: Indictment of the Shiite Clerics of Isfahan, (London: Routledge, 2017, with S. McGlinn); Of Piety and Heresy: Abū Ḥāmid Muḥammad Ghazzālī’s Persian Treatises on Antinomians, (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2024); “Rūmī’s Antinomian Poetic Philosophy,” in Mawlana Rūmī Review, IX, No. 1-2, (2018), 159-99. His recent publications are edited books Gender and Sexuality in Persian Literary and Religious Traditions: Embodied Encounters, (Leiden: Leiden UP, 2026); and Dancing before God’s Beauty: Exploring Rūmī’s Poetic Universe, Mystical Philosophy and Reception History, Berlin: De Gruyter, 2025. He is a member of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences (KNAW). At the moment, he is the Principal Investigator (PI) of an ERC-Advanced Grant entitled Beyond Sharia: The Role of Sufism in Shaping Islam (www.beyondsharia.nl).
Ufuk Erol (online)
Constructing Superstition: Sufism, Orthodoxy, and State Power in the Early Modern Ottoman Empire
The concept of superstition has long been a key term in Islamic historiography. The reductionist classification of Islam as Sunnism, Shiism, and Sufism in the modern period has utilised this concept to define Sufism as an irrational and superstitious set of beliefs and practices diverging from the Islamic norms of Sunnism and, at times, Shiism. While superstition became a scholarly term within the study of religion in the nineteenth century, its use as a discursive tool among Muslims has a long history that precedes the modern period. This paper explores how Sufism and Sufi groups were described and categorised in the sixteenth and seventeenth-century Ottoman Empire through claims, castigations and accusations of superstition. The period in question was marked by the rise of a centralist and state-centric Sunnism, which aimed to consolidate state power by disciplining local socio-religious identities. This process inevitably brought about a fluorescence of discourses (re)categorising and often marginalising certain socio-religious groups that were not content with state-centric Sunnism. The word batıl (superstitious) was a term widely used to describe the religious practices of those groups at times accused of being fasık (deviant) and meczub (lunatic). The paper utilises both archival and hagiographical sources, including Vahidi’s Menâkıb-ı Hâce-i Cihân ve Netîce-i Cân, a significant work providing detailed accounts of Sufi groups and representing the efforts of defining “true” Sufism and normative Sufi practices in the sixteenth-century Ottoman Empire. Overall, this paper demonstrates how superstition functioned as a useful concept and discursive device in the early modern Ottoman Empire to reconfigure the boundaries among Sufism, religion and power.
Ufuk Erol is a postdoctoral research associate at the Leibniz Institute of European History. He holds a PhD in History from Indiana University Bloomington. Employing a historical-anthropological approach, his dissertation and forthcoming book examine the transregional history and marginalization of Qizilbash-Alevi communities in eastern Anatolia from the early modern period to the modern era. His broader research interests include Islam, Sufism, and politics in Iran and the Ottoman Empire.
Keynote (Chair: Gökçen B. Dinc)
Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm
The Demon’s Gate: Towards a Global History of Religion–Science–Superstition
In 1916, the pioneering Japanese philosopher Inoue Enryō published Meishin to Shūkyō (Superstition and Religion), combining a global catalogue of superstitious beliefs with a call for the modernization of Buddhism, geared toward a popular audience. Central to his project was the distinction between “superstition,” “religion,” and “science.” Inoue’s project did not emerge in a vacuum. Across the globe, from the nineteenth into the early twentieth century, intellectuals were debating the relationship between these three categories.
Taking Inoue’s text as its departure point, alongside interventions by Lu Xun in China and Swami Vivekananda in India, this talk will begin to sketch a global history of the religion–science–superstition triad.
For much of European history, superstition had been understood as the false double of religion: improper worship, idolatry, magic, or traffic with demons. With the emergence of the category “science,” superstition increasingly came to designate the opposite of scientific truth. Yet older conceptual distinction did not completely vanish. Instead, “religion” and “science” were frequently defined in opposition to one another and also via opposition to “superstition” as a third term. From the vantage of religion superstition was false religion; from the vantage of science superstition was false science. What counted as superstition, however, varied considerably. The accusation itself could become a powerful instrument of colonial governance, religious reform, or the policing of legitimate knowledge.
Although the terminology originated in Europe, Non-European intellectuals contested and creatively redeployed the three terms, translating them in creative ways, and sometimes turning the accusation of superstition against Western institutions. Following these debates across linguistic and geographical boundaries, I will argue that the global history of superstition is also a history of struggles over who could define the boundaries of religion and science.
Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm is an historian and philosopher of the Human Sciences. He is currently Francis Christopher Oakley Third Century Professor of Religion and Chair of Science & Technology Studies at Williams College. Storm received his Ph.D. from Stanford University, his MA from Harvard University, and has held visiting positions at Princeton University, Harvard University, École Française d’Extrême-Orient, Ruhr Universität, and Universität Leipzig. He is the author of The Invention of Religion in Japan (2012), The Myth of Disenchantment: Magic, Modernity and the Birth of the Human Sciences (2017), Metamodernism: The Future of Theory (2021), and The Genealogy of Genealogy: Nietzsche, Foucault, and the Coils of Critical History (2026) all published by University of Chicago Press.
Panel 3
Chair: Irene Stengs
Irene Stengs is guest researcher at the Meertens Instituut (KNAW) and emerita professor by special appointment “Anthropology of Ritual and Popular Culture” at the Vrije Universiteit. Important research foci are popular religiosity, material culture, commemorative ritual and processes of heritage formation. She is in particular interested in the relation between heritage-making, emotions and the role of ritual in processes of sacralization. Presently she works on the (ritualised) relationships between people and trees.
Markus Balkenhol, Meertens Institute Amsterdam
Trefu. Afro-Surinamese food taboos and the entanglements of memory, the body and the supernatural.
Trefu are very specific food taboos in Afro-Surinamese (including Creole and Maroon) cosmologies. They are passed down through the paternal line, but can also be acquired later in life, for instance when they are revealed in dreams. Breaching such taboos has been thought to cause leprosy and other skin diseases and allergic reactions. Trefu are part of an Afro-Surinamese cosmology in which biomedical and supernatural aetiologies intersect. Europeans have regarded such taboos as superstition, and rejected them as both unscientific and as magical thinking, thus disregarding both Afro-Surinamese belief and medical systems. This intersection of religion, superstition and science was part and parcel of European imaginations of racialized boundaries between self and other. Based on my ethnographic work with Surinamese therapists and Winti practitioners in the Netherlands, I show how trefu today are situated within a broader memory politics around the afterlives of slavery and colonialism, and in particular the uneven relationship between the Afro-Surinamese Winti religion and Christianity. Trefu, I argue, are good to think through the entanglements of superstition and science, knowledge and embodiment, and memory and the supernatural.
Markus Balkenhol is a senior researcher at the Meertens Institute. He is interested in colonial heritage and memory, in particular the afterlives of slavery in the Dutch Kingdom and the intersections of memory, religion and healing. He is part of the NWA research project Slavery Past Present. Dutch Slavery and Colonialism and Their Present-Day Impact. He is also member of the contact group for the project Koloniale Macht en Kennis, researching the colonial past of the Royal Dutch Academy of Arts and Sciences (KNAW). Markus is a board member of the Netherlands Association for Anthropologists (NEVA).
Gertrud Hüwelmeier, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
The Transformation of Superstition into Intangible Cultural Heritage. Spirit Mediumship in late-socialist Vietnam
In late-socialist Vietnam, “religion” and “the secular” once again become important categories in political discourse and in everyday life. As in many other post-socialist countries the category of superstition still plays a crucial role. In North Vietnam, a number of popular religious practices were considered superstition and banned by the communist regime after the end of French colonialism (1954). However, after the introduction of a socialist market economy in the late 1980s the government’s view of superstition has gradually changed. From this time onwards, initially hesitant and more visible since the 2000s, prosperity cults, pilgrimages and spirit worship flourish in many places.
In the first part of my paper, I sketch briefly the way in which superstition was framed historically. By focusing on the state-mandated promotion of communist atheism during the Second Indochina War (1955–1975), I analyze the state’s approach to religion and the distinction drawn between religion and superstition. As part of the effort to instrumentalize religion to shape “new socialist individuals,” popular religious practices—such as trance mediumship—were banned, and ritual specialists were required to attend re-education courses.
The second part of my paper focusses on the resurgence of spirit mediumship in North Vietnam since the 2000s. Based on ethnographic fieldwork conducted over a period of 15 years, I attended numerous séances—at a time when mediumship was still shrouded in secrecy and not practiced publicly. However, once the Ministry of Culture, striving to advance national unity, recognized that national heroes of the past were being venerated and appearing as spirits in trance ceremonies, things began to change. Following the official recognition of spirit mediumship as a national Intangible Cultural Heritage of Vietnam in 2012 and its inscription on the UNESCO Representative List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity in 2016, keen interest in these performances emerged, and even local government officials began acting as spirit mediums. A few years ago, trance mediumship was even practiced by professional actresses at a state theater.
Despite a relaxation regarding certain popular religious practices, the category of superstition remains significant in present-day Vietnam. As in the past, people seek out fortune tellers and soul callers. However, the practice of spirit mediumship has made the leap to the global stage after being recognized as Intangible Cultural Heritage; in doing so, it fuels the booming tourism industry, spawns numerous charlatans, and is evolving into a lucrative business.
Gertrud Hüwelmeier is an anthropologist and Senior Research Fellow at Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin. She has published widely on religion, transnationalism, media and materiality. Her ethnographic fieldwork focuses on cross border social, religious and economic ties of migrants between Vietnam and post-socialist Europe. In the past decade, she has conducted research in Vietnam on urban renewal, ecologies and ghosts in the city. Publications include the co-edited book Traveling Spirits. Migrants, Markets and Mobilities (Oxford/New York: Routledge, 2010), and articles on “Spirit writing in Vietnam: Political Lessons from the Beyond”, (2019), The Asia Pacific Journal of Anthropology, 20(3): 278-293; “Feeding the spirits – cooking, offering and reclaiming lộc in late socialist Vietnam”, (2021) South East Asia Research (1): 108-125; “The sacred Cowshed Tree in urban Hanoi – a home for unredeemed souls” (2022), Material Religion18 (3): 311-332; “Colonial ghosts, the French cemetery and urban renewal in Hanoi” (2022). The Asia Pacific Journal of Anthropology. 23 (3): 232-249.
Ananya Pattnaik, Indian Institute of Technology (online)
Tales of Janis: Supernatural Threat, Accusations of ‘Guni-garini/Sorcery’ and Contestations around Religious bBoundaries
As Kandhas, an Adivasi (indigenous) community in the Eastern Ghats of India, fashion themselves as Hindus or Christians through conversion projects, their disposition towards their prior cosmological and ritual order comprising of deities, spirits, and other supernatural agents is being reshaped. Hindu and Christian authorities, alongside state developmental discourse, condemn certain Kandha practices through the idiom of andhabiswas (blind belief), denoting ‘superstition’ or ‘false religion’, while selectively recognizing and appropriating other aspects of indigenous ritual life. These interventions have transformed how supernatural threat, ritual legitimacy and social difference are understood within the community. Crucial to this transformation is the role of janis, ritual specialists historically responsible for communicating with village deities and defending against supernatural danger including threats posed by human acts of sorcery colloquially referred to as ‘guni-garini’, among the Kandhas. With the death of the senior and last-existing janis, and the absence of successors, older forms of ritual
authority are weakening, engendering anxieties over who can legitimately manage supernatural threats. Against this milieu, the paper asks how is supernatural threat regulated under conditions of religious transformation and shifting structures of ritual authority? How are distinctions drawn between legitimate/ moral and illegitimate/ dangerous ritual powers and practices, and who gets to make those distinctions? Exploring these questions through the contested categories of magic, religion, science and superstition, within anthropology of religion, I argue that amid conversions to new religions, accusations of guni-garini/ sorcery are crucial sites through which religious identities and community boundaries are negotiated. As pre-existing checks and balances on supernatural power weaken and new religious formations emerge, tensions and suspicions around guni-garini become difficult to resolve. This opens avenues for Kandhas to draw upon Hindu, Christian and state discourses to redefine distinctions between legitimate and aberra
Ananya Pattnaik is a doctoral research scholar in the Department of Humanities and Social Sciences at the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, India. Her research interests include anthropology of religion, indigeneity, religious conversion, and ethno-nationalism.
Panel 4
Chair: Ernst van den Hemel
Ernst van den Hemel is researcher at the Meertens Institute and Professor by Special Appointment of Religion in Heritage and Popular Culture at Utrecht University. He leads the ERC-funded MAKEBELIEF project (www.makebelief.nl/en).
Pooyan Tamimi-Arab
Spinoza’s account of superstition and critical theory
Superstition (superstitio) is a central concept in Spinoza’s Theological-Political Treatise, first published in 1670, and described by orthodox contemporaries as a book “forged in hell.” The treatise is arguably the first European defense of democracy based on a notion of universal rights, and in this sense marks a turning point in the development of modernity. In this presentation, I reflect on the function of superstition in Spinoza’s account of religion and how he ties this to his politics, and reflect on how this notion has been received and used in our time in differing contexts, in particular in receptions of Spinoza in Brazil and Iran, as part of the conceptual toolbox of critical theory.
Pooyan Tamimi Arab is associate professor of secular and religious studies at Utrecht University, where he leads a mixed-methods research project on secularization in Iran. His current work on Spinoza brings him to this symposium on superstition: he is co-editing a special issue of the Journal of Spinoza Studies on Spinoza’s Theological-Political Treatise, with articles on the reception of Spinoza in Brazil, the Netherlands, Turkey, Iran, and India.
Gökçen B. Dinc
Gendering Superstition: Why Annemarie Schimmel Was an Exception
A leading Orientalist, Annemarie Schimmel (1922–2003), was appointed to Ankara University’s Faculty of Theology in 1954, becoming the first professor of the History of Religions in Turkey. During her five years in Ankara, Schimmel not only contributed to the institutionalization of the discipline but also supervised Hikmet Tanyu, whose doctoral research examined saint veneration, a widespread practice common to Sunni Muslims and Alevi-Bektashis, Turkey’s largest religious minority. While Alevi-Bektashi traditions were marginalized and excluded from the realm of legitimate religion through discourses of “superstition” promoted by state authorities and religious elites in Republican Turkey, Tanyu contributed to the feminization of saint veneration and its devaluation as “superstition,” thereby marginalizing an overlapping dimension of Sunni and Alevi-Bektashi religiosity. In doing so, he reinforced the construction of legitimate religious knowledge and authority as masculine. Schimmel, by contrast, incorporated Alevi-Bektashi traditions into her scholarship without reducing them to superstition, heterodoxy, or heresy, unlike many prominent male Orientalists of her time. She furthermore recognized women as integral to the history of Islam and Sufism. By examining Schimmel’s exceptional approach to popular religiosity in Turkey and expressions of Islam in Turkish, this presentation seeks to uncover the gendered hierarchies embedded in discourses of superstition, a dimension that has received limited scholarly attention.
(see bionote above)
Panel 5
Chair: Birgit Meyer
(see bio above)
H. Işık, Mimar Sinan Fine Arts University and Department of Sociology at İstanbul Bilgi University
Negotiating Authority: The Continual Reclassification of Superstition in the Turkish Daytime Television Programme Müge Anlı ile Tatlı Sert
Recent scholarship has shown how superstition has shaped the historical boundaries of religion, secularism, and modern subjectivity, challenging its treatment as religion’s irrational counterpart. Building on this literature, this paper examines superstition as a classificatory category through which occult claims are negotiated among competing authorities in contemporary Turkey. I argue that rather than being a failure of classification, continual reclassification enables these authorities to intervene and redraw the boundaries between religion, fraud, illness, crime, and morality. The analysis draws on cases involving occult claims featured on the daytime television programme Müge Anlı ile Tatlı Sert. Here, “occult” names the broader practices under examination, while “superstition” refers to the category through which the programme makes them intelligible. Rather than treating the programme as a representation of popular belief, I examine it as an arena where religious, psychiatric, medical, legal, and moral interpretations confront one another publicly. The paper develops three arguments. First, occult claims move between categories such as superstition, fraud, psychological disorder, religious exploitation, and criminality, allowing different authorities to claim jurisdiction. Second, cases involving magic reveal how the programme rejects magic’s efficacy while taking the intention to perform it seriously. Superstition separates ontological efficacy from moral intention, and magic becomes impossible yet morally terrifying. What matters is not whether magic works, but what the desire to use it reveals about intentions to harm. Third, these classifications produce shifting subject positions. Women appear as perpetrators, victims, dupes, caregivers, or morally redeemable subjects, while religious healers become charlatans, mentally ill individuals, religious exploiters, or potential criminals. Superstition, then, I argue, is not a residual belief displaced by modernity but a means of organizing authority, intervention, and moral judgment around the occult.
H. Işık (they/them) is a PhD student in Sociology at Mimar Sinan Fine Arts University and a Research Assistant in the Department of Sociology at Istanbul Bilgi University, both located in Istanbul, Turkey. They hold a BA in Sociology from Boğaziçi University and an MA in Visual Arts and Visual Communication Design from Sabancı University. Their research interests include the sociology of visual culture, queer and trans studies, sociology of religion, and memory studies, with a particular focus on gender, representation, and power. They are an independent visual artist and filmmaker whose practice engages with documentary cinema, animation, and visual storytelling.
Hermen Kroesbergen
Superstition as adding the wrong kind of reality to religion
Superstition is a category that is used in the context of religion; therefore, it is important for religious studies to take into account the role it plays. One religious group may use this pejorative category to discredit another religious group, and within one group (or one life) it plays an important role as well. It represents that one’s own religious practice may go wrong. In this paper, I will argue that this danger often concerns adding the wrong kind of reality to religion, and this is crucial in acknowledging the kind of reality religion has. I will illustrate this using examples from the Netherlands and Zambia. As a pastor in the Netherlands, I visited someone who had survived a severe accident. People told him he must have had an angel on his shoulder. He was aware that this was just an expression, he told me, but for him it was real as well. It was clear by the way he spoke of it that he did not mean this in any literal sense, yet it was real for him. It has been a year since, and I have never heard him speak of angels again. Literal angels, or a theory of how angels arrange all things on earth, was something he wished to avoid – he would consider it superstition – nonetheless, in the moment, speaking of the angel on his shoulder meant something important and real to him.
Father Bernhard Udelhoven, a Roman Catholic priest, mediated in many cases of witchcraft accusations in rural Zambia. He describes how at times witchcraft beliefs are very important and real for people, but when tensions subside, the witchcraft accusations are no longer treated as important either. People would still claim that witchcraft exists, but it is no longer relevant to determine which uncle or nephew used witchcraft. Witchcraft beliefs oscillate, Udelhoven concludes.
In both examples, superstition is a category used within one’s own religious perspective, and in both cases this perspective becomes superstitious if pinned down. To understand the kind of reality involved in religion, it is important to see the kind of reality it avoids. Superstition is adding the wrong kind of reality to religion, the kind that does not allow for the oscillation described in the examples. Focusing on the use of superstition as a tool of power between religious groups risks presenting the different groups as having a stable set of beliefs, without acknowledging this kind of oscillation and the kind of reality attached to it. I will argue that within religious groups and individuals the contrast between genuine religion and superstition is important. Critical religious studies benefits greatly from paying attention to the role that superstition in this sense plays within religion.
Hermen Kroesbergen is a philosopher of religion and systematic theologian. In 2015 he wrote an article to defend the use of ‘superstition’ as a descriptive category within Wittgensteinian philosophy of religion. In his 2019 book The Language of Faith in Southern Africa he applied the Wittgensteinian perspective to his experiences living for 9 years in Africa (Zambia and South-Africa). In Faith Envy: Kierkegaard, Wittgenstein and Weil on Desirable Faith (2021) he discusses the common phenomenon of people saying they are sometimes a bit jealous of having faith. In 2024 he edited the volume The Grammar of the Spirit Wolrd in Pentecostalized Africa. Currently, Hermen Kroesbergen serves as a minister in the Protestant Church in the Netherlands in Zuiderwoude, Uitdam and Broek in Waterland.
Adeyemi Johnson ADEMOWO, Department of Sociology, Afe Babalola University, Ado-Ekiti, Nigeria
Who Be Witch? Interrogating Superstition, Ageing, Gender and the Politics of Accusation in Contemporary Nigeria
Despite advances in education, urbanization and scientific rationality, witchcraft accusations remain a persistent feature of social life in Nigeria, as well as in many African societies. In contemporary Nigeria, allegations of witchcraft continue to shape social relationships, define moral boundaries and produce categories of vulnerable persons. This paper interrogates the social construction of the witch figure by asking a deceptively simple but profoundly important question frequently heard in everyday discourse: Who be witch? Drawing on our ethnographic encounters, anti-witch-hunting advocacy initiatives, media reports and community engagements conducted in Akwa-Ibom and Ekiti states, southern Nigeria, the paper examines how accusations emerge, whom they target, and the social conditions that make particular individuals susceptible to suspicion. The analysis demonstrates that witchcraft allegations are rarely random. Rather, they are disproportionately directed at elderly women, widows, socially isolated individuals, children, and others occupying vulnerable social positions. In this context, accusations function not merely as expressions of belief in supernatural causation but as mechanisms through which communities negotiate uncertainty, misfortune, conflict and social change. The paper argues that superstition operates as a powerful category of social classification that transforms suspicion into social fact and moral legitimacy. Through everyday narratives of illness, death, infertility, economic hardship, and family crises, individuals become marked as dangerous others whose exclusion, punishment, or stigmatization is rendered acceptable. Consequently, superstition serves as a technology of social regulation that reinforces existing inequalities relating to age, gender, power, and social status. By shifting attention from the truth or falsity of witchcraft claims to the social consequences of accusation, the paper contributes to emerging debates on superstition as a constitutive category in the making of modern social worlds. It demonstrates how accusations of witchcraft continue to mediate relations between belief, morality, vulnerability, and violence in contemporary Nigeria, while revealing the enduring power of superstition in shaping social identities and boundaries.
Professor Adeyemi J. Ademowo is a distinguished scholar of Social Anthropology and Development Studies, Provost of the College of Social and Management Sciences, Afe Babalola University, Nigeria, and Founding Director of the Centre for Indigenous Knowledge and Afro-Diaspora Studies (CIKADS). A University of Ibadan-trained academic, he is a BIARI Fellow (Brown University), IFRA Fellow, and AHP/ACLS Fellow. His scholarly contributions span African epistemologies, indigenous knowledge systems, cultural studies, urban anthropology, human security and sustainable development. An author, researcher and academic mentor, he advances interdisciplinary scholarship, international research collaborations and African-centred knowledge production, connecting academic excellence with institutional innovation, policy engagement and societal transformation.